Are bionic superhumans on the horizon?
By Ramez Naam, Special to CNN
April 25, 2013 -- Updated 1227 GMT (2027 HKT)
(CNN) -- We're in the midst of a bionic revolution, yet most of us don't know it.
Around
220,000 people worldwide already walk around with
cochlear implants -- devices worn around the ear that turn sound waves into electrical impulses shunted directly into the auditory nerve.
Tens of thousands of
people have been implanted with deep brain stimulators, devices that
send an electrode tunneling several inches in the brain. Deep brain
stimulators are used to control Parkinson's disease, though lately
they've also been tested -- with encouraging results -- in use
against severe depression and obsessive compulsive disorder.
The most obvious bionics
are those that replace limbs. Olympian "Blade Runner" Oscar Pistorius,
now awaiting trial for the alleged murder of his girlfriend, made a
splash with his Cheetah carbon fiber prostheses. Yet those are a
relatively simple technology -- a curved piece of slightly springy,
super-strong material. In the digital age, we're seeing more
sophisticated limbs.
Consider the
thought-controlled bionic leg that Zac Vawter used to climb all 103 floors of Chicago's Willis Tower. Or the
nerve-controlled bionic hand that Iraq war veteran Glen Lehman had attached after the loss of his original hand.
Or the even more sophisticated
i-limb Ultra,
an artificial hand with five independently articulating artificial
fingers. Those limbs don't just react mechanically to pressure. They
actually respond to the thoughts and intentions of their owners,
flexing, extending, gripping, and releasing on mental command.
The age when prostheses
were largely inert pieces of wood, metal, and plastic is passing.
Advances in microprocessors, in techniques to interface digital
technology with the human nervous system, and in battery technology to
allow prostheses to pack more power with less weight are turning
replacement limbs into active parts of the human body.
In some cases, they're
not even part of the body at all. Consider the case of Cathy Hutchinson.
In 1997, Cathy had a stroke, leaving her without control of her arms.
Hutchinson volunteered for an experimental procedure that could one day
help millions of people with partial or complete paralysis. She let
researchers implant a small device in the part of her brain responsible
for motor control. With that device, she is able to
control an external robotic arm by thinking about it.
That, in turn, brings up
an interesting question: If the arm isn't physically attached to her
body, how far away could she be and still control it? The answer is at
least thousands of miles. In animal studies, scientists have shown that a
monkey with a brain implant can control a robot arm
7,000 miles away.
The monkey's mental signals were sent over the internet, from Duke
University in North Carolina, to the robot arm in Japan. In this day and
age, distance is almost irrelevant.
The superhuman frontier
The 7,000-mile-away
prosthetic arm makes an important point: These new prostheses aren't
just going to restore missing human abilities. They're going to enhance
our abilities, giving us powers we never had before, and augmenting
other capabilities we have. While the current generation of prostheses
is still primitive, we can already see this taking shape when a monkey
moves a robotic arm on the other side of the planet just by thinking
about it.
Other research is pointing to enhancements to memory and decision making.
The hippocampus is a
small, seahorse-shaped part of the brain that's essential in forming new
memories. If it's damaged -- by an injury to the head, for example --
people start having difficulty forming new long-term memories. In the
most extreme cases, this can lead to the complete inability to form new
long-term memories, as in the film Memento. Working to find a way to
repair this sort of brain damage, researchers in 2011 created a
"hippocampus chip" that can replace damaged brain tissue. When they
implanted it in rats with a damaged hippocampus, they found that not
only could their chip repair damaged memory -- it could
improve the rats' ability to learn new things.
Nor is memory the end of
it. Another study, in 2012, demonstrated that we can boost intelligence
-- at least one sort -- in monkeys. Scientists at Wake Forest
University implanted specialized brain chips in a set of monkeys and
trained those monkeys to perform a picture-matching game. When the
implant was activated, it raised their scores by an average of 10 points
on a 100-point scale. The implant
makes monkeys smarter.
From disabled to super-capable
Both of those
technologies for boosting memory and intelligence are in very early
stages, in small animal studies only, and years (or possibly decades)
away from wide use in humans. Still, they make us wonder -- what happens
when it's possible to improve on the human body and mind?
The debate has started
already, of course. Oscar Pistorius had to fight hard for inclusion in
the Olympics. Many objected that his carbon fiber prostheses gave him a
competitive advantage. He was able -- with the help of doctors and
biomedical engineers -- to make a compelling case that his Cheetah
blades didn't give him any advantage on the field. But how long will
that be true? How long until we have prostheses (not to mention drugs
and genetic therapies) that make athletes better in their sports?
But the issue is much,
much wider than professional sports. We may care passionately about the
integrity of the Olympics or professional cycling or so on, but they
only directly affect a very small number of us. In other areas of life
-- in the workforce in particular -- enhancement technology might affect
all of us.
When it's possible to
make humans smarter, sharper, and faster, how will that affect us? Will
the effect be mostly positive, boosting our productivity and the rate of
human innovation? Or will it be just another pressure to compete at
work? Who will be able to afford these technologies? Will anyone be able
to have their body, and more importantly, their brain upgraded? Or will
only the rich have access to these enhancements?
We have a little while
to consider these questions, but we ought to start. The technology will
sneak its way into our lives, starting with people with disabilities,
the injured, and the ill. It'll improve their lives in ways that are
unquestionably good. And then, one day, we'll wake up and realize that
we're doing more than restoring lost function. We're enhancing it.
Superhuman technology is on the horizon. Time to start thinking about what that means for us.
<< Home